F Juice.com

Ryan Leaf (32)

ESPN listed Leaf first on both their list of the 50 biggest NFL draft busts and their list of the 25 Biggest Sports Flops between 1979 and 2004. MSNBC commentator Michael Ventre went so far as to call Leaf “the biggest bust in the history of professional sports.” Each year, some sports writers speculate on which drafted player will be the “next Ryan Leaf”, that is, the next big college superstar to flop in the pros.

In February 2001, Leaf married a Chargers cheerleader, Nicole. They separated two years later and divorced soon after.  

Emmitt Smith (39)

Rod Smith (38)